Take the 2-minute tour ×
Physical Fitness Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for physical fitness professionals, athletes, trainers, and those providing health-related needs. It's 100% free, no registration required.

What do smart lifters do when they're working out alone and want to do benchpresses?

I have a busy schedule, and it isn't practical for me to have a regular weightlifting partner. I've usually avoided regular benchpresses in favor of either dumbbell benchpresses or smith-machine benchpresses. I like to lift to failure on my final set (or at least get very close to it), and don't want to get trapped under a bar. Also, constantly having to get a spot from strangers in the suburban globo-gym I lift at seems like an imposition.

I see other people benchpressing alone all the time, so I can only assume that my fears are a little exaggerated. What do smart lifters do in that situation? Just not go to failure? Switch to a smith machine for the last set(s)? Just not feel guilty about asking a stranger for a spot?

Details about my background - I'm currently benching a pair of 60lbs dumbbells for 3 sets of 7, and feel comfortable controlling the weight. But I'm curious about switching over to working with a barbell.

Thanks.

share|improve this question
add comment

6 Answers

up vote 4 down vote accepted

The best thing to do is to use a bench station with safeties. Whether those safeties are sawhorses from the hardware store, a power rack, or a squat rack with safety attachments; they will prevent the bar from trapping you on the bench. The safeties should be low enough that you can touch the bar to your chest, but high enough you can slide out from underneath if you need to rest the bar on the safeties.

Even when you aren't training to failure, and have a prescribed number of reps you are aiming for, sometimes failure is inevitable. Using safeties lets you lift without fear of hurting yourself seriously.

Pros of using safeties:

  • You are still in control of your schedule
  • You can lift confidently, knowing you will never be trapped
  • You will never have to worry about someone who thinks spotting means performing rows while you bench--and the awkward view of this person's crotch while they perform the joint exercise.

Cons of using safeties:

  • It can wipe you out unloading the bar, putting it back on the pins and reloading.
  • A hand-off can make or break a max attempt--and if you don't have one you will spend a lot of energy getting the bar off the pins.
  • You may gain the ire (anger) of people who want to use the power rack and don't know what you are doing. People who have pushed themselves to their limits regularly will recognize what you are doing.

If you can get someone to lift with you, or just give you a hand off, that can make things a lot better. If you grab a random guy in the gym, make sure they understand you only want them to hand you the bar and you don't want them to interfere with the bench in any way.

share|improve this answer
add comment

I would go with doing the bench press in a squat rack. Set the pins at the right height, even if you fail you won't get crushed by the bar.

share|improve this answer
1  
Yep, a support like squat/power rack is a great way to be safe. You need some way to fail... –  Greg Aug 5 '12 at 17:27
add comment

I stopped benching alone because I didn't trust this method to be enough, but I used to leave off the plate clips. That way, if I get stuck, I can tip the bar to one side and slide the plates off with a huge crash. It would probably damage the floor and/or the plates, but I would be able to get up. I never had to implement this strategy.

Any system that is able to set an actual safety bar just below the level of your puffed-out chest would be superior. You should test the system with an unloaded bar to make sure you can squeeze out from between the bar and the bench.

share|improve this answer
    
I have done the bar tip, once, when I first started and didn't have a good sense of where failure was. In my case the floor and plates were OK, but it turned some heads. –  Chelonian Aug 7 '12 at 17:11
    
@Chelonian hehe - yeah I think most lifters out there have had this experience once upon a time! –  Mike S Aug 8 '12 at 1:01
add comment

I only increase my bench press by 2.5lbs per workout, and only if I did three sets of five reps in the previous workout. So, I know I can definitely get a few reps completed before failure. I know what my second-to-failure rep feels like and don't do another rep if I think I may fail on it.

If I've gotten 2 sets of 5 done, and I really want to try for a new 3x5 and don't want any uncertainty about the last rep, I just ask another random person who looks like they're resting to spot me on my last set.

share|improve this answer
add comment

I think you answered the question by properly asking it. Don't go to failure. Should you be cautious about benching? YES, I think this is the exercise where people actually get hurt the most, by the bar dropping on them (chest or much worse the throat). I would recommend using barbell in the beginning of your routine and as you get tired, moving to dumbbells. This will give you the experience in using barbell training and the ability to push it with reduced risk of injury using dumbbells.

I workout alone (home gym) and had two experiences where I couldn't lift the bar off of me...dumping to the side (as Dave mentioned above) is the option, you can also purchase safety standsenter image description here.

share|improve this answer
1  
I use adjustable-height metal sawhorses instead of safety stands. 1000lb version ran me maybe $30 from the hardware store. –  Greg Aug 5 '12 at 17:25
    
@MeadeRubenstein "don't go to failure" - terrible advice for someone looking for gains. –  Mike S Aug 6 '12 at 1:20
2  
@MikeS - NOT going to failure when you're benching on your own and have no way to unload/stop the bar from doing damage is great advice. On the other hand - Going to failure as planned WEHN a spotter is present is good advice.. –  Meade Rubenstein Aug 6 '12 at 11:58
    
@MeadeRubenstein Obviously I'm saying he should rush out and buy some apparatus so he CAN go to failure and see some real gains. Wasting your time otherwise. Our bodies are an adaptive organism. Push it beyond what it can currently do, and it will grow to accommodate your new activities. Repping away without straining yourself waiting for the magic fairy to bless them with muscle once you've gone through the dance routine - I see it all the time. There are so many people at my gym doing that and looking the same year after year. Here's the 'secret': PAIN - HARD WORK - PAIN. –  Mike S Aug 6 '12 at 22:51
1  
@MikeS - I agree that you should push yourself beyond your current capacity, and no two workouts should be the same, but I'm not sure going to failure all the time is necessary....from what I read (Rippetone, Don John, others) it's a tool to be used as part of a plan. I agree with the hard work and associated pain, there's no magic pill...I think this goes with wearing belts, wraps, etc. - lots of advice on either side and it comes down to what works best for the specific person. –  Meade Rubenstein Aug 7 '12 at 6:27
show 7 more comments

One more thing to look into is what is commonly referred to as "the roll of shame". Personally, I don't think the name is very fitting, as it's a perfectly good method of controlling the bar when coming a bit closer to failure than expected...

What you do is that when you can't quite get the weight up, you lower it towards your stomach, roll the bar downwards to the hips, and sit up. From here you can move the legs and put the bar to rest on the bench. Be careful if you need to remove the weights here, as the support is in the middle, and it's easier for the bar to flip over.

Of course, if you have a weight way over your maximum, you will not be able to do this easily, but then again that is not really the situation we're looking at here.

It can be a good idea to practice the move a few times with submaximal loads, just to get the hang of it.

Oh, and one more thing - avoid the smith machine. That's where you can really get stuck if you fail and don't succeed with fastening the bar. Quite a number of serious accidents has happened in the smith.

share|improve this answer
    
so you'd recommend the power rack then with the safety squat bars? –  Mike S Aug 8 '12 at 1:03
    
The "roll of shame" is a method that can be employed when you have no safety bars, just the bench. The power rack, safety stands or similar equipment is absolutely safer, but this is a viable option when none of that equipment (or spotter) is available. –  Markus Wall Aug 8 '12 at 9:37
    
I tried the roll of shame once, and it really hurt rolling over my pelvis –  Mike S Aug 8 '12 at 23:18
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.