5

I've read that doing weighted pull-up and dips with weight using straps can lead to hernia and lower back problems.

(specifically damaging intervertebral disc and pressuring femoral artery(with straps))

How true is this? (I'm 172cm, 85kg) using ~12kg backpack for pull-ups and dips, was going to use ~20-24kg weight with straps on belt

  • this might help: fitness.stackexchange.com/a/21014/7091 – Eric Jun 8 '15 at 0:04
  • Can't really back it up with source at the moment, so I'm just posting this as a comment. I think I saw a video by Athlean-X a few months back where he actually talks about pull-ups being good for your spine because the weight forces your back to decompress, which counters all the compression forces in squats for example. Maybe someone know what I'm talking about and can give credit. Hope that helps. – Suimon Feb 18 at 10:20
3

Progressive weights and good forms are usually deterrent against injuries. when it comes to weightlifting.

The exercise itself will not result in any injury; however, you'll injure yourself if you use a weight your body isn't prepared to carry. This is because the weight will be automatically shifted to the lowest part of your back, where more pressure will be applied.

Also, using a wide belt like this

properly distributes the weight and reduces the pressure on your spine.

So, use a good belt, start with low weights and progressively increase it, and use proper form and you should be safe.

  • so going from 12kg to 24 is too much? – Herokiller Jun 5 '15 at 19:06
  • That's an 100% increment (excluding your own weight). I don't increase weights that fast; your mile may vary. Just listen to your body and adjust. – Kneel-Before-ZOD Jun 5 '15 at 19:18
4

Short answer

Don't worry about it.

Longer answer

Weight belts are NOT going to give you any problems unless you pack on an obscene amount of weights. And this is a catch-22 anyway, because the weight you'd need to strap to yourself is way more than you'd ever be able to do pullups or dips with.

You should always opt for a belt which can be tightened pretty snugly around your waist. And the more surface area the belt covers, the better, because it spreads the pressure out.

Backpacks, I have less experience with in terms of dips and pullups. But in the army, we ran 30k (~18.6 miles) with pretty substantial backpacks, in addition to helmets, rifles and vests. We also did a lot of obstacle courses with the same stuff imposed on us. I have a hard time seeing that we'd be doing this if it were known to cause back problems.

This is of course barring any problems you have already which might be worsened through physical exercise.

About herniae

I have an umbilical hernia (which I've not yet opted to treat because it's not causing any problems), and I've had a couple visits to the doctor just to get some info on it.

First off, there are a large set of different ways a hernia can arise. Physical exercise doesn't usually cause it, but it can make existing herniae more protruding and more noticable.

Personally, I notice mine when doing abdominal work, but this is because mine is located at the belly button, and I suppose is subjected to some pressure when my abs are flexing.

  • I'm not sure whether you understood it correctly, the weight is not the belt itself, but some kettlebell hanging on straps – Herokiller Jun 5 '15 at 7:44
  • @Herokiller - Yes, I figured that this was implied. Of course the weight of the belt itself is trivial. – Alec Jun 5 '15 at 13:47

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.