Physical Fitness Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for physical fitness professionals, athletes, trainers, and those providing health-related needs. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this community
This goes along with a prior question, what over-training signs to look for. Is there such a thing as over-training? or is it that you injure yourself from lack of proper training and don't perform at peak because of bad planning? So, the question is, Is there such a thing as over training?
Related Article: Max Out on Squats Every Day
The article you site refers to the Bulgarian method, which produces world class lifters who can handle the high intensity, constant training, and become very strong because of it. But propenents tend to not mention all of the people who are spit out the back of the Bulgarian system because their bodies can not handle the strain.
It is the people that can not handle constant training that can over train, and that is the majority of the population. Over training is exacerbated by two things especially:
Bad form: You see this in baseball pitchers. They throw hard for months, but bad form combined with too many pitches leads to injury. These are not necessarily instantaneous injuries, but often injuries related to tearing and inflammation, which could have been avoided with fewer pitches, more rest, or especially, better form.
Overloading the eccentric movements: Eccentric movements occur when a muscle is extended as it is trying to contract. For example, when lowering a weight to the floor, fighting gravity, your bicep is contracting, but the weight is extending the muscle at the same time. This movement can cause substantial gains in strength, but excessive weight, or excessive numbers of movements can cause long term injuries such as tennis elbow.
My guess is that the person profiled in the article above is used to the average person leaving his gym, while the genetic anomalies stay and successfully work within his program.
Added comments: It is my opinion that non-injury symptoms of over training are really caused by under recovery. In other words, you could potentially deal with the problem by sleeping more, or eating better, rather than necessarily reducing the workout.
My favorite quote by John Broz is:
If you can't go into the gym and squat heavy twice a day, every day, you aren't overtrained, you're undertrained.
Greg Glassman defined overtraining as:
Overtraining is not sleep deprivation, soreness, or systemic or musculo-skeletal fatigue due to excessive training volume. Overtraining is a neuroendocrine beat down associated with excessively intensive work – more rest won’t necessarily help, reduced intensity will.
He then goes on to say:
Why is it that those most inclined to worry and ask about “overtraining” are about as likely to set a new record in the Olympic Decathlon as they are to ever overtrain?
I've personally done months solid of very high intensity 14-20 per week training sessions with outstanding results. It's difficult, and takes twice as much time outside of the gym to "pamper" just to stay healthy.
In my opinion, don't worry about overtraining. You'll know when it's time to scale it back.
This is a really good sciency article on the Bulgarian method written by a phd in neurobiology. I think our friend Bee may have been in the "Dark Times". It seems those who can power through are the most successful, while those who can't fail.
P.S.: I trained under Broz' philosophy for a few months. Squats every day. It's horrible. I don't recommend it unless you're competing. I did make some serious progress though.
Overtraining truly does exist - I am proof of that. I have been a competitive swimmer my whole life (currently 22years old) and I must say overtraining is horrible and should try and be avoided at all costs.
I would recommend getting help as soon as you start to see issues arising, rather than continually deny you have a problem (like I did) until it's too late.
I was forced to take months off from training, since my body was physically, mentally and socially wrecked from the daily hammerings by body received from training.
I experienced the following:
So, the question is, Is there such a thing as over-training?
Short answer: yes. You can push yourself further and further into fatigue that you start getting weaker the more work you put in. Over training will have signs of depression, negative affects on health markers like blood pressure, total body inflammation, increase in body fat, and more. In the worst cases you may experience rhabdomyolysis.
How difficult is it to over-train?
This is actually something that people should be concerned about. Many novices are quick to worry about over training when they really can't train hard enough to get there. Some people confuse fatigue with true over training.
The folks over at Juggernaut Training Systems are fond of using the analogy that your work capacity is like a cup. The work that you put in fills the cup with fatigue. The things you do for recovery empties that cup. Over training happens when you over-fill the cup.
An article entitled "Fatigue Explained" discusses a number of the physiological issues surrounding fatigue and what you can do about it:
Unless you are an elite athlete, it takes most trainees a long time of pushing very hard to truly get into a place where you could say they are over-trained. There are several ways of managing fatigue, and well written training programs will build some of these features in for you.
Many successful programs vary both volume and intensity. You start out with lower intensities and higher volume, and each week increase the intensity while doing fewer reps overall. After the heaviest week is usually a deload of sorts to allow your body time to more fully recover and essentially create a bigger cup. When the next cycle starts, you are using slightly heavier weights.
Yes, you can overtrain. The main theory of the training is a overcompensation/supercompensation theory: http://healthcorrelator.blogspot.com/2010/08/theory-of-supercompensation-strength.html
Overtraining is a training when you body can't compensate and overcompensate damage made by workout.
There is an example of the thee different workouts, where the first is a result of overtraining.
Over training is a common problem in some athletic circles where raw power is desired, but excessive training builds up endurance instead. Boxing comes to mind and can be spotted when a boxer doesn't break a sweat in the early rounds.
Of course over-training exists--the body takes time to heal and recover from exertion.
Lack of recovery can also lead to acute injuries beyond the normal wear-and-tear.
