3

Today, a man in the gym told me that it is useless to do more than one type of shoulder press exercises. I do two exercises, one with dumbbells and one with a lift. Is he right or not?

2

Doing more than one shoulder exercise for increased hypertrophy is perfectly logical.

However, there's a diminishing return on how much hypertrophy you can achieve by simply doing more of the same type of exercise in one session.

So for instance, if you've done 3 sets of barbell OHP, followed by 3 sets of dumbbell OHP, I don't see a problem. But if you're doing 10 sets of the first, and another 10 sets of the latter, that's definitely overkill. You might achieve more muscle growth by splitting that up into shoulder AND chest for instance.

-2

If you are talking about Over Head Presses, I would suggest against doing them, reason being Shoulder Impingement and restriction of shoulder moment due to shoulder biomechanics. Shoulder doesn't performs the function of pushing the arms upward. Rather shoulder raises, front, side and back would be more beneficial without any negative effect. Please look at this video.

  • People have been pressing for hundreds of years. With good form it is hard to impinge using a barbell. The usually cause of impingement is lateral/front raises and behind the neck press done incorrectly. – Gunge Nov 7 '16 at 8:10
  • When was the last time you used or saw someone using this movement to lift something above head beside in the gym. The point was that same or better shoulder muscle development can be achieved by doing lateral raises without putting shoulder muscles or nerves at risk. But to each his own, I have been using lateral raises in my workout for each shoulder head, and have achieved nice results. I am not an expert on bodybuilding, and speak strictly from my own experience. Please go though the video. He is an expert at what he does, and hope that you will understand the point he is trying to make. – Gaurav Nov 17 '16 at 10:19

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.