16

In response to this answer, I was curious what exercises specifically target the abdominal muscles. Answers given so far include:

My question is two-fold:

  1. What's wrong with the age-old crunch?
  2. What other good abdominal exercises are there?
27

Probably the biggest problem with the age old crunch is that it is not functional. The crunch flexes the trunk and primarily targets the rectus abdominis, not the transversus abdominis or the obliques. If you want a flexed trunk when you stand up then doing lots of crunches will give it to you.

However, if you want an elongated mid section with strong abdominal muscles creating a solid core and support for your abdomen then you want to use postural exercises such as the plank, progressing the length of time you are able to maintain the hold, which translates into functionally controlling the torso. Also, by drawing your navel in towards the spine with these types of exercises you target the transversus abdominis which flattens the abdominal wall more than other ab muscles. The transversus is especially important in lifting.

If your goal is to have 6 pack abs then you need a low percentage of body fat which is generally achieved with diet, HIIT and strength training to burn calories.

Some suggestions of other good abdominal exercises that carry over into improved posture and function are: The plank, side plank, bird dog, progressing to dynamic control with dying bug, knee tucks on a swiss ball or swiss ball roll outs. Using resistance bands helps to target the obliques.

  • Dear @BackInShapeBuddy, fantastic info, thanks: just to clarify: do you put leg raises in the same category as crunches, or in the let's say "better" category of planks. Thanks. – Fattie Oct 22 '11 at 10:20
  • 1
    @Joe, In this leg raise link you will see that there is a stabilization as well as dynamic function of the abs (see the comment area). Also, whether done in this position or in the hanging leg raise position, you can see that it adds more to your workout as it is more of a total body exercise than crunches. Go for it! – BackInShapeBuddy Nov 3 '11 at 3:32
  • 2
    Awesome answer! Thanks! FYI my favorite ab exercise is this one. It's SUPER tough and has lots of scalability. – Daniel Jan 28 '13 at 1:20
6

Some of the more advanced versions of leg raises are:

windmill

inclined leg raises

hanging leg jacknife

And when you get strong enough, you can do weighted versions of these. You can use a dumbbell in between your feet for the weighted version, just be careful though.

  • 1
    basically you do those 3 when you hit plateau on the normal leg raises. – Carlos Jaime C. De Leon Aug 19 '11 at 7:25
  • +1 for the windmill. After flag, in my opinion, the hardest abdomenal exercise. – StupidOne Aug 19 '11 at 7:32
  • speaking of flag, I forgot to mention something similar to that, its called the dragonfly, from bruce lee, but this link here is from rocky 4. I don't do it too much as I'm not strong enough for that one: [link] youtube.com/watch?v=ihky09eKsEI&feature=related – Carlos Jaime C. De Leon Aug 19 '11 at 7:39
5

The problem with crunches is that they aren't very effective for the purposes that most people choose them:

  • If you are doing crunches because you want to show off a "six-pack" then you'll never get there, as this is mostly about getting to low body fat rather than building larger ab muscles.
  • If you are trying to increase core strength, then crunches are equivalent to doing a very high-rep low-weight exercise, which does not build strength.
  • 1
    What's stopping you from grabbing 30 kg weight? Suddenly, crunches are low-rep high-weight exercise which does build strength. – StupidOne Aug 19 '11 at 7:02
  • 1
    Nothing, but that's no longer an "age-old crunch", it's a modified version... – G__ Aug 19 '11 at 13:41
0

Someone above described planks as a "postural exercise". That might be true in theory, but in practice it is a different matter. Visit your typical gym and just watch the people doing their planks. They are all doing terrible things for their posture. Their scapulas are winging, their thoracic spine is going into kyphosis (hunchback), and their cervical spine is protracted (forward head posture). This is especially the case when people try to do planks for a maximum amount of time, which is fashionable on facebook and youtube.

If you are going to do planks, have someone watch you and adjust you and keep you honest. Once your form shows any sign of deterioration, stop. After that point, you will just be imprinting bad posture into your nervous system (engram).

New contributor
Chris is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering. Check out our Code of Conduct.
-1

I don't do ab exercises yet I can see my abs. What I do targets them indirectly, squats, dead-lifts, standing shoulder press, shrugs, etc. For the little time I have to train, 2 for 1 (ie full body exercises) is the best way to go.

  • What is more optimal, having a strong core or having an unbalanced core just for the sake of having a "6 pack" and ignoring the other regions of the core? – PmanAce yesterday

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.