0

I have not done a squat or a deadlift in close to 4 weeks. I overtrained and hurt MCL- based on what I read online I think it was a class II tear. I haven't had any pain for my re than a week. If I body weight squat I do feel a little discomfort. My questions would be the following:

  1. Should I wrap my knees during squat and deadlift?

  2. What is an optimal foot position for relieving sheer force on the mcl?

  • 2
    What about getting a concrete diagnosis rather than guessing from some online reading? – rrirower Sep 1 '17 at 19:05
  • Dont do DEADLIFT, SQUAT all had injury and nobody expose it, they kept it secret by not telling injury's. – YumYumYum Sep 8 '17 at 9:18
0

Yes you need to be seen.

  • Knee braces i.e. CopperFIT do nothing. If you're orthopedically evaluated - if indicated - they'll recommend a brace.

  • A grade II MCL sprain means it's partially torn (to what degree?) however it sounds like this was a self diagnosis


Realize a few things here:

  • Collagen is avascular and consists of fibers that run parallel to each other. (this provides it's tensile strength).

  • It heels slowly and if you're not receiving proper rehab the fibers heal in a random "spaghetti" like pattern. As the majority of fibers are no longer parallel it provides little support and a full tear becomes likely.


  • With an MCL tear medial movements should be painful - avoid knock-knee positions (genu valgum).

  • Your foot position doesn't really matter in this case. This does not change the fact your MCL is still partially torn.

  • Your knee position is what you need to watch. Minimize lower extremity movements toward the midline of your body.

| improve this answer | |
0

I am no doctor but

  1. I don't think that knee wraps are used for the purpose of supporting damaged joints. If body weight squats cause discomfort weighted squats should be avoided. Also I think knee wraps aren't that good for recovery because they restrict blood flow in the area.
  2. I am not qualified to answer this question.

That said I cannot stress enough how careful you should be with your knees. Ligaments grow slowly and take longer to repair than muscle. I seriously advise you to see a medical proffessional and enjoy some low impact and "easy on the joints" sports. Swimming, cycling (not off-road), etc. I have a friend who tore a ligament and it is something I would urge you to avoid.

| improve this answer | |
  • That's good advice. I actually had no diagnosis - so it's pure conjecture. I don't want to make it worse. – Brian Turner Sep 1 '17 at 22:11

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.