3

Lets say, I want to do 100 pushups daily in one go, or improve my overall ability to do Pull ups.

I am not strong enough now to do that now.

If I do 100 pushups, spreading over the whole day, will I get less benefits that doing 100 pushups in one go?

What would be a better way to give Load & Recovery to my body for best results?

  • Is your objective to do 100 pushups, or to figure out which Training Protocol will have better overall muscle / fitness performance & recovery benefits? My answer was geared based on the latter. – Alex S Jul 20 '18 at 12:23
  • @AlexS , I am gearing towards latter – Graviton Jul 20 '18 at 13:15
  • Then your question needs to change as it seems to be focused and titled on 100 Push up challenge as the GOAL. – Alex S Jul 21 '18 at 5:13
1

To understand the problem, let’s look at two extremes. Suppose that Person A does 100 Pushups in 100 Seconds while Person B does 100 Pushups in 100 Hours. If we assume that both persons are equally fit, then we can conclude that Person B isn’t even being challenged. Why? Because a single pushup every hour is hardly enough to sufficiently challenge this person’s muscles if they are capable of doing 100 in 100 seconds.

Now let’s bring this back to the realm of the reasonable. If you can do 100 Pushups in less than an hour, then you should do them all at once. Why? Because your muscles will continue to feel the effects of consecutively doing more. If you spread it out too much, you start to not challenge yourself. Your body completely recovers between sets, and you never need to push yourself further than what you are comfortable with. It’s in the challenging parts that your muscles will grow and improve, so embrace it and you’ll continue to improve.

| improve this answer | |
  • Makes sense. But being able to do 100 pushups in a day is no small feat – Graviton Jul 18 '18 at 13:33
  • @Graviton - It depends on your strength:weight ratio. If you are obese with little muscle then it might be pretty challenging, but otherwise it’s really not anything crazy. The program that I’m currently following has something called a “400 Challenge” which consists of 100 repetitions of four excersises; push-ups, sit-ups, squats, and inverted rows. The initial goal is to do it in less than 17 minutes which plenty of people accomplish. Sure, it’s not easy, and not everyone gets it on their first try, but I don’t believe that anyone who sticks with the program has ever not passed eventually. – JustSnilloc Jul 18 '18 at 14:57
  • I follow this same "no pain, no gain" mentality. I don't know if it's the best for your body, but 100 Pushups in 100 Hours is certainly nothing to brag about, either. – jp2code Jul 20 '18 at 14:50
1

I was posting a brief comment and as I submit I realised it had become longer and maybe I might as well post as answer.

From what I've read from various sources including Pavel, working at 50% of ones max capacity and not to failure is best for growth, recovery & repeated stimulus/ training.

We don't know if 100 is your max to failure. But let's say if you can do 1 set of 10 pull-ups max, the.

You're better off doing multiple sets of 4/5 that are spread out to prevent failure; the spread can be over a workout or a day or many sets through the week; provided you get recovery between the 50% Sets.

So spread is on your recovery ability to work again while avoiding the negatives of working to failure.

So you get to overall put in more work, resulting in greater growth in capacity.

Of course the caveat is don't do heavy workout during lunch or around hot afternoons. It's better work the body mornings/ evenings when body & nature are both less prone to heating up; timing for better capacity and recovery.

Ps: Don't negative vote if you just want references. I will post some when I'm at a PC. Doing it from the phone is a pain. But I figured if I start the post it will help

There lots of books with chapters on this concept and articles but finding them and reading them is gonna take longer. So I am linking to experts who are actually talking about it for now; they also mention Pavel's concepts

And for all your focus on 100 push ups I am wondering how you missed this:

| improve this answer | |
  • 2
    Any luck on the references? – Sean Duggan Jul 18 '18 at 14:06
  • @SeanDuggan Will try to post over coming weekend as I'll be retreading some of that material as well. For a quick recall 1. Recent Joe Rogan interview of Faras Zahabi, coach of Goerge St Pierre 2. Interviews of Coach Sommers - Gymnastic Bodies 3. Grease the Groove / GTG for pullups 4. Pavel Tatsouline - look up articles/ interviews/ books around his training protocols & periodisation I think – Alex S Jul 19 '18 at 3:37
  • Not going to downvote, but the only bad part about spreading your workout over the whole day is that most people will not warm up every time. Young people often do not see the need in warming up, but it is tearing joints apart that will manifest itself as arthritis later in life. Just be cautious. – jp2code Jul 20 '18 at 14:47
  • @jp2code - Sure. But we are not discussing pre & post workout schematics else this would be required in every Q&A - hopefully understood & assumed. Also, its not about SPREADING through the day, but allowing more stimulus without going to failure by better WORK to RECOVERY balance. – Alex S Jul 21 '18 at 5:16

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.