5

Should the weight of the bar fall on the palm of the hands or on the fingers?

  • 1
    The current world record for deadlift is 500 kg. I'll assume a "heavy deadlift" is modestly only twice the lifter's body weight. If such a lifter can keep the bar in the palm of their hands throughout the lift, more power to them. I suspect that most mere mortal humans cannot, and as such lift the bar on their fingers. – Roger Oct 31 '18 at 19:56
10

The hand should be wrapped around the bar as much as possible, but the wrist would be straight down. I guess that would mean the bar would fall on the palm right under the knuckle of the hand.

However, a common issue, especially as the weight gets heavier, is the bar will roll away from the palm. There are a couple strategies people use to mitigate this:

Mixed Grip:

enter image description here

You hold the bar as you would with overhand grip, but one hand is facing forward. The rolling is offset so the bar is easier to hold.

One major downside to this method is it can cause a massive imbalance over time. You have to switch which hand is facing forward in order to prevent this imbalance.

Another issue is there is an increased risk of bicep tear in the arm that's facing forward.

Downsides aside, it is probably the most used technique.

Hook Grip:

enter image description here

This method of grip is where you put your thumb under the fingers. It creates an extremely strong hold. It also does not come with the downsides of the mixed grip.

However, it hurts a lot the first few times you do it. There's no real way to get around that. After the initial hazing phase though, you won't even notice.

Given the options, I would recommend learning hook grip. The sooner you get used to it, the better off.

Photos courtesy of (stolen from) breakingmuscle.com.

|improve this answer|||||
1

DeeV's answer didn't give the third option: using weightlifting straps. With straps, you use a double overhand grip and the straps keep the bar touching the palms of your hands.

Unless you plan on being a competitive powerlifter, there is no reason to use either hook grip or mixed grip. Both hook grip and mixed grip tear up your hands without really developing your grip strength; there are much better ways of developing grip strength than deadlifting with hook grip or mixed grip. "Strongman" competitors usually have very good grip strength but use straps for their deadlifts in competition (and also frequently in training).

I used to do heavy deadlifts with a mixed grip. But all this did was tear up the skin on my hands so that I wasn't able to do as much volume with exercises that actually do build grip strength like farmer's walks, weighted pullups, or heavy rows. Now I start out my deadlifts with double overhand grip. Double overhand grip on deadlift actually does build grip strength (unlike mixed or hook grip). For my heavier sets, I always use straps. This saves the skin on my hands and thumbs so that I can do a higher volume of pullups and rows.

The whole point of this answer is that mixed grip and hook grip deadlift do not actually build overall "grip strength". For example, John Haack and Cailer Woolam both have extremely strong mixed grip and hook grip deadlifts respectively. But when they did Jujimufu's "grip gauntlet", they did not demonstrate especially good overall grip strength.

|improve this answer|||||
  • 2
    There really is no reason to use straps unless maybe when you're trying to set a new PR. DeeV's answer actually covers far better solutions than using straps. Using straps is just a shortcut to never actually try to improve grip strength. The fact that strongman competitors use them in competition doesn't justify using them every time you want to deadlift heavy. – MJB Nov 2 '18 at 7:44
  • I would say it's the opposite. People competing in Strongman should use wraps. Strongman use axle bars, speed pulls, and super high max. They also have to save their strength for the other events. Other exceptions I can think of are people deadlifting on very high volume days and want to save their thumbs, or people deadlifting in the 700s or higher. – DeeV Nov 2 '18 at 12:41
  • I wouldn't say straps are only for PRs. Once every blue moon, you might want to do a set of very high reps, and straps will make sure you can focus on proper form rather than slipping and re-gripping every time the bar touches the floor. Though I will add that DLing without straps is a good way to improve grip strength, and help catch up. – Alec Nov 2 '18 at 12:43
  • I have to agree that you could use them once in a while to go for high reps, or to be able to focus on your form while not having to focus on the grip. But I still think 95% of your DL training should be without straps. – MJB Nov 2 '18 at 14:56
  • 1
    @MJB Why do you think 95% of DL training should be without straps? Maybe if one is a competitive powerlifter this would be true, but why would this be true for someone interested only in general strength and conditioning? – J. Heller Nov 6 '18 at 17:34

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.