1

When performing the bench press, usually you are advised to pinch your shoulder blades back and down in order to get your shoulder joint in the most stable/safe position. Also it's pretty common to advise forming some sort of arch.

The pushup, being fairly similar in terms of muscle activation and actual movement, does not get this treatment. At least I have never heard or seen someone advise to pinch the soulders back during a pushup. Obviously you won't be able to form an arch during the pushup. But why does nobody seem to advise to pinch your shoulder blades back and down?

2

Both the (prominent) arch and the shoulder squeeze during benchpress are forms that are most common in powerlifting. For bodybuilding-style or strength endurance training, they are unnecessary or even counterproductive.

The arch

The reason for making an arch is two-fold: First, it prevents shoulder impingement as the arch ensures that the angle between your locked-out arms and your upper body is below 90°. Second, it reduces the range of motion as it raises your chest, thus allowing you to lift more weight (at the expense of an optimal training stimulus).

When doing push ups (in the common form), your hands are usually around the same height as your chest, so when you are fully extended, your upper body and your arms form an angle less than 90°, which essentially replaces the need of an arched lower back.

The squeezed shoulders

Again, this form has two purposes useful mainly for powerlifting: It further reduces the range of motion just like the arch. Plus, it provides further stability - once you press several times your body weight for a single repetition, you need all the stability you can get.

When doing pushups, you automatically let your upper body hang through as you get closer to failure, which is essentially the same as pinching shoulders. The reason that no one is recommending doing so? It's probably because bench pressing is commonly seen as a competitive movement - you want to move as much weight as efficient (i.e. reduce the range of motion) as possible while still adhering to the rules; while pushups are usually utilized as a functional exercise - you want to maximise the training effect, reducing ROM would be counterproductive.

TL;DR both the arch and the 'shoulders back and down' are powerlifting techniques that are inteded to allow you to lift bigger plates at the expense of a training effect.

  • +1 for mentioning that arching the back is mainly for powerlifting. I see far too many people doing this in the gym who are simply training for strength, even though it limits range of motion and therefore gains. – Will Appleby Oct 8 at 12:50

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.