3

Prolonged sitting is bad, the same goes for standing. Okay, how about regularly shifting between the two by some given intervals, is that still bad?

  • 1
    Moving around generally helps to alleviate the problems associated with holding one position for too long. – JustSnilloc Jun 30 at 1:53
4

Interestingly, the risks of mortality between the two conditions, sitting and standing, appear to be causally different.

Our understanding of the former is supported by a large body of research demonstrating a general association between sedentary time and mortality. However, occupational sitting is not strongly associated directly with diseases like diabetes and heart disease. Hence, it appears that sitting is not inherently bad for us (at least in terms of mortality) but because we are not moving enough.

By contrast, the latter has most recently been associated directly with heart disease, adding to the body of research linking it to other health conditions “such as lower back and leg pain, cardiovascular problems, fatigue, discomfort, and pregnancy-related health outcomes.” The authors of the first paper, above, suggest that excessive standing may be causally linked to heart disease as a consequence of “blood pooling in the legs, increased pressure in the veins and increased oxidative stress, ... which can contribute to an increased risk.”

It should be noted that this research has been focused on prolonged occupational standing, without the opportunity to sit or move. Indeed, more generally, it is recommended that both prolonged static sitting and standing postures be avoided. So yes, the literature certainly does support the notion of shifting regularly between the two conditions. And of course, we should be as active as we can outside of our sedentary occupations.

I hope that is helpful.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.